AGAINST by Ellie F
I’m not asking members to reject endorsing Janeese Lewis George because it is too risky. Much of what we do as socialists is risky. I am asking members to reject endorsing Janeese because it would weaken the socialist, anti-imperialist and abolitionist horizons of our organizing.
JCRC of Greater Washington is not just a Jewish advocacy organization, if that label is even accurate. It one of many Zionist institutions which shields itself from criticism by saying it speaks for the Jewish community. Here at GMU, JCRC worked with our Hillel to lobby university administration to stop pro-Palestinian activism on campus, resulting in our Board of Visitors further engraining the false IHRA Definition of Antisemitism on campus. Across the region, JCRC has lobbied against municipal ceasefire resolutions, calling them a threat to Jewish safety. If the goal was to connect with the Jewish community, Janeese has already been working with progressive Jewish groups such as Jews United for Justice. Paying to be a panelist at a JCRC event did nothing but contribute to the normalization of Zionism.
Even with the pro-Palestine elements of her record, participating in a Zionist lobbying event and ambiguous QnA responses on Palestine make Janeese Lewis George ineligible for endorsement under the national and local Anti-Zionist Resolutions. This is not to mention her support for DC hiring 800 more police officers. It’s not worth breaking policies determined by our own membership for a membership bump and the prestige of the mayoral office.
When Janeese inevitably folds to pressure from capitalists and the federal government (which could be a personal failing, systemic or both), I fear our chapter leadership will not have the courage to act. Their failure to even publicly acknowledge Janeese’s mistakes, like our movement partners in Jewish Voice for Peace did in a statement published to their Instagram, does not inspire confidence. I worry we will prioritize supporting whatever reforms make it past the DC Council, Congress and the White House over fighting for a socialist future. Such an approach would quickly condemn us to division and irrelevance. To build socialism, we must build workers’ power at the grassroots level. We must especially improve our outreach to the marginalized communities we say we fight for. Embracing opportunistic electoralism will only have us running in circles.